Electric baseboard or a furnace at COP 1 is almost always the expensive way to heat when a gas line is available. A heat pump changes that, because it moves heat instead of making all of it from electricity.

At current U.S. average prices

Using EIA residential averages (electricity year-to-date, gas as a heating-season average, propane and oil as of the week of November 16, 2026):

  • 95% gas furnace: about $15.09 per million Btu delivered.
  • Electric resistance (baseboard, or a furnace at COP 1): about $53.31.
  • Heat pump at a seasonal COP of 2.5: about $21.32.

Resistance heat costs several times what gas does at those averages. A heat pump narrows the gap and can beat gas where electricity is cheap, but it is not automatic. Enter your rates in the calculator or check the heat pump vs gas break-even table.

When electric heat still makes sense

A well-insulated small space, a home with no gas service, or a heat pump in a mild climate can be reasonable. Straight electric resistance as the main heat in a cold, average house is usually the high-cost option, even before winter demand charges.