Where a house already has a gas line, the running-cost question is usually heat pump versus a natural gas furnace, not versus propane. The math is the same idea as the propane comparison, but the break-even COP is often higher because gas is usually cheaper per Btu.

The break-even COP versus gas

A heat pump is cheaper to run than a 95% gas furnace when its seasonal COP is higher than the cost of electric heat at COP 1 divided by the cost of gas heat:

break-even COP = (electric $/kWh ÷ 3,412) ÷ (gas $/therm ÷ 100,000 ÷ 0.95)

In Minnesota, with electricity at 16.4¢/kWh and heating-season gas at $1.04/therm (EIA), the break-even COP is 4.40. That is a tougher hurdle than the propane comparison on the same house, because gas delivers heat so cheaply.

Break-even by state

Using EIA heating-season residential gas prices and year-to-date electricity prices:

StateGas $/thermElectricity ¢/kWhBreak-even COP
Arkansas$2.0813.71.83
Florida$2.2515.31.90
Louisiana$1.8113.32.04
Texas$2.0216.02.21
North Carolina$1.7814.92.34
Hawaii$5.4046.42.39
Arizona$1.7815.42.40
Washington$1.6114.42.49
Georgia$1.6215.52.65
Oregon$1.6015.52.69
South Carolina$1.6415.92.71
Missouri$1.4614.32.72
Alabama$1.6716.52.75
Mississippi$1.5115.12.77
Oklahoma$1.3813.82.79
Kentucky$1.4114.22.81
Virginia$1.6216.92.92
Delaware$1.6518.03.04
Tennessee$1.2413.83.09
Kansas$1.3415.33.17
Nebraska$1.1012.93.27
West Virginia$1.3315.63.27
Massachusetts$2.4630.23.42
Utah$1.0513.23.51
Wyoming$1.0614.03.69
Maryland$1.6121.33.69
Rhode Island$2.1529.03.77
Nevada$0.9813.43.81
New Hampshire$1.8626.94.02
North Dakota$0.8512.54.08
Pennsylvania$1.4421.14.09
Vermont$1.6323.94.10
Iowa$0.9814.64.11
California$2.1632.64.19
New Mexico$1.0215.34.21
South Dakota$0.9414.64.30
Ohio$1.2018.84.37
District of Columbia$1.5824.94.39
Minnesota$1.0416.44.40
Colorado$1.0516.84.44
Indiana$1.0717.04.45
Connecticut$1.6927.54.53
Montana$0.8514.14.64
Wisconsin$1.1119.14.80
Maine$1.7430.24.83
New Jersey$1.3824.14.87
New York$1.6529.34.94
Illinois$1.0319.25.21
Idaho$0.6913.05.26
Michigan$1.0321.75.87
Alaska$1.2627.36.05
Assumes a 95% AFUE gas furnace. Lower break-even favors the heat pump. Cheap electricity and expensive gas help; the reverse hurts.

What this comparison leaves out

Fixed monthly gas-service charges, backup electric resistance on the coldest days, installation cost, and incentives are not in the table. A dual-fuel setup (heat pump plus the existing furnace) is often the practical answer in a cold climate — see the dual-fuel guide. Use your own rates in the heating cost calculator.